• Berry Ever After
  • Berry Ever After
  • Berry Ever After
  • Berry Ever After

Berry Ever After

Blueberry cheesecake…but in fudge form.

A dreamy blend of white chocolate fudge, sweet blueberry, and real graham cracker chunks. It is rich, tangy, and totally addictive.

✔ Cheesecake-inspired flavor
✔ Sweet + slightly tangy balance
✔ Smooth with bits of graham crust
As low as $10 a jar when you build a 4-pack · mix any flavors
BUILD YOUR BOX — STACK & SAVE
2 jars$24 total $12 / jar 3 jars$33 total · save $3 $11 / jar 4 jars$40 total · free shipping · save $8 $10 / jar · best value Build your box
mix & match any flavors →
🚚Ships in 24h
❄️No fridge
🎁Gift ready
💜Guaranteed
Visa · Mastercard · Amex · Shop Pay · Apple Pay

Sugar, White Chocolate (Sugar, Palm Oil, Whole Milk Powder, Nonfat Dry Milk, Soy Lecithin, Vanilla.), Marshmallow Creme (Corn Syrup, Sugar, Water, Dried Egg Whites, Artificial Flavor, Cream of Tartar, Xanthan Gum, Blue 1), Salted Butter, Heavy Cream, Milk, Graham Crackers (unbleached enriched flour, graham flour, sugar, soybean oil, honey, leavening, salt, soy lecithin, artificial flavor., Blueberry flavoring (propylene glycol, natural favors, benzyl alcohol, FD&C red 40, FD&C blue 1), Propylene glycol, water, natural and artificial flavors., Sea Salt

Spoon it, or melt it

Blueberry cheesecake vibes

Blueberry cheesecake vibes

Sweet blueberry, creamy base, and just the right hint of tang

Creamy with a crunch

Creamy with a crunch

Smooth fudge with real graham cracker pieces throughout for that perfect bite

Feels a little fancy

Feels a little fancy

Dessert-worthy, rich, and the one you bring out when you want something different

Why you’ll get hooked

✓A whole jar of your favorite bite — no knife, no fuss, just a spoon.
✓Real ingredients, made in small batches in Tennessee.
✓Soft, creamy, and spoonable straight from the jar.
SPOONABLE FUDGE • NO KNIVES REQUIRED • SHIPS NATIONWIDE •SPOONABLE FUDGE • NO KNIVES REQUIRED • SHIPS NATIONWIDE •

FAQ

Find the most frequently asked questions below.

What makes your fudge different?
We're not your grandma's fudge (though she'd probably love it too). Our flavors are playful, nostalgic, and made in small batches, with a soft, creamy texture that's spoonable straight from the jar.
How long does it last? Do I need to refrigerate it?
Shelf life is about 2 months — always check the Best By date on the bottom of your jar for the exact date. Unopened, keep it at room temperature somewhere cool and dry. Once opened, store it in the fridge for freshness, then let it soften 10–15 minutes before digging in.
Will it melt in transit?
It ships safely at room temperature, double-sealed for freshness. In warm months it may arrive soft — pop it in the fridge for 20–30 minutes to firm up. In cold months, let it sit out 10–15 minutes to soften.
Any dairy-free, nut-free, or gluten-free options?
Some flavors are naturally gluten-free or nut-free, but all fudge is made in a facility that may handle dairy, nuts, soy, and gluten. Check each flavor's page for details.

Explore more flavors

Classic Peanut Butter
Classic Peanut Butter
VIEW FLAVOR Cookies 'n Dream
Cookies 'n Dream
VIEW FLAVOR

Real reviews from Fudge Fairy fans 💜